The cadet was kicked off the officer-training course pending an investigation into the remarks, which were made at RAF Cranwell. The air force has launched a probe into the incident. The comment occurred during a question-and-answer session where cadets were asked about dangers to British security.
The cadet was taking part in a 24-week Modular Initial Officers Training course at RAF Cranwell just before Easter. The cadet and 50 other students were asked to give presentations and answer questions about the biggest security threat to the UK. Historically, Islamist extremists have committed some of the worst atrocities on UK soil, including the 2005 London Underground bombings and the 2017 Manchester Arena attack.
If I'd asked that question and got that answer I would have also asked the cadet to expand on his thinking and got some critical thinking going rather than suspend him.
In recent years, Iran has also emerged as a significant concern for UK security. Britain has responded to more than 20 plots backed by Iran since 2022. The UK government has said the threat from Iran to the UK is 'persistent and unacceptable'.
Defence Secretary John Healey said the UK's terror threat level was under review after the outbreak of war in Iran. Retired rear admiral Chris Parry criticized the RAF's handling of the incident, accusing the air force of shutting down critical thinking of new officers around controversial issues. Parry said the cadet should be reinstated.
Clearly Islamic extremism is the issue and not Islam, but how are young people expected to develop critical thinking around these complex issues if they are shut down in this way?
This is the fault of a system that is training its young people but not allowing them to express themselves and develop their thoughts.
Any mature educational establishment should do just that.
If this cadet had answered 'the far-Right' I doubt he would have been suspended.
We know that Islam is not a threat, rather it is extremist elements, and this appears to have been a missed opportunity to discuss that for fear of causing offence.